eriksmartt.com/blog

Interface design on Sparkfun’s new GeoChron

Interface design on Sparkfun’s new GeoChron

Sparkfun just released a new, stand-alone GPS logging device, which looks to be a slick alternative to all the “mobile-device + Python + bluetooth GPS” hacking I’ve resorted to for similar tasks. It’s a pretty tempting package if you need dirt-simple GPS logging. However, I’m a bit confused by the switches. Take a look at the picture of the device below:

There are two toggle switches: one for on/off, and one for standby/run. Take a minute to look at the switch diagrams and labels, and think about how to use this device. How do you turn it on? How do you make it start logging?

Now that you’ve thought about it, was it clear? What does the ‘1′ on each switch mean to you? What does the graphic under each switches label mean? Ignore the ‘1′ and ‘0′ and look just at the diagram. Based on the graphic alone, which switch position should “on” be?

I used to get the ‘1′ vs. ‘0′ on switches backwards when my mental model was of the ‘0′ indicating a completed circuit. Now I use a binary metaphor, where a ‘1′ bit is on, and a ‘0′ bit is off. That seems to be what the switch means. But if I take that approach on the GeoChron, then the standby/run switch is installed backwards. Personally, I think I’d drop the graphic under the switch labels (I think it’s more confusing then helpful), and flip the standby/run swtich so that ‘1′ means ‘run’, and so that the switches are both pressed in the same direction when the device is on and logging. With a device this simple, you really shouldn’t have to think about how to turn it on. (I still want one though ;-)